Phish - Camden, NJ 6/10/2011 Mini-Review Thing
"Every Phish show is good," my cousin Bill agreed with the guy sitting next to us during setbreak at the Saturday Vegas 2004 show. "Except for Thursday night," the guy added. "And last night... wasn't that great," clarified Bill. "Yeah, and that first set... wasn't very good either." The two nodded in agreement.
Why are many of us, as phans, inclined to think and talk this way? Seems silly to invest so much time, energy and money, only to inevitably complain about the outcome, no? There is definitely a spectrum of reactions to what Phish does nightly on the web. There are those who lash out with angry, impotent hate and there are others who feel that they need to honestly assess the performance without "fluffing" it. The latter is a delicate balancing act. I personally like to think that Phish knows what they're doing and wouldn't benefit from my advice. I try to remain thankful for the fact that the band is playing shows and that I have an opportunity to see and hear them. However, in practice that gratitude is sometimes all too human and flawed.
I relate this because these thoughts raced through my head as I hoped to see something great at Phish's appearance at Susquehanna Bank Center in Camden, NJ. I had just seen a show in Mansfield, MA (p.k.a. Great Woods) the previous Tuesday and was frankly disappointed with it. It was good because it was a Phish show, but not a lot of standouts. I'd seen 5 shows since Phish returned in 2009 and caught many repeats of songs that don't particularly excite me. I missed the "Llama" opener at Mansfield which might have been a huge highlight for me. The Darien Lake show the next night looked like a crazy setlist that would have been awesome to see. So, it was up in the air what kind of show I'd see at Camden, usually a venue that is reputed to host amazing Phish concerts. This time we got in early enough that I did not miss the opener = off to a good start. "Rocky Top" opener was huge! A longtime favorite of mine. I don't see or hear every Phish show on the tour, so a real deal Mike's Groove with "I am Hydrogen" is big for me. A great one to have seen! I have been chasing "Stash" since Phish started the current era and was thrilled to hear it.I recall thinking to myself at this point, "How could Phish possibly screw up this show?" I received the answer soon enough: a 3.5 minute radio edit version of Tube. Then, "Guyute." I tried to enjoy the lights and the composed section in the middle.
Things picked back up for me when they busted into a "Guelah Papyrus," my first. "Scent of a Mule:" not a favorite either, but the crowd went crazy for it and it boasted a duel with some interplay between Trey and Page which I enjoyed. I used to dislike "Cavern," but I dig it now and I was happy to hear it live. Mike tore it up on that tune, but it was short. "The Sloth" is a good tune, IMO, and though this one wasn't the greatest version it was fun. I intuited at this point that none of these songs were from before 1994, which was impressive to me. "The Curtain" set-closer (HD video) was unexpected and people around me were wondering if we'd hear a "..With." Yes! This was welcome, and an unexpected way to end the set, with a melodic jam.
I hit up the Phellowship meeting at the setbreak in Mansfield, and it was a major high point of the show for me. I was able to hang with a lot of positive folks and felt good. I went to the table for the meeting in Camden to celebrate my 3rd sober show. I ran in to some friends and was happy for the fellowship of the folks there. It solidified why I was there doing what I was doing.
I heard the spacy tones that would likely signify "Down with Disease" as I ascended the stairs and sure enough, it dropped. I enjoyed the jam that it morphed into, but I have to say that I am hugely into the Providence Fall 2010 "...Disease" opener which this didn't compare to, for me.
I was hyped to hear a "Free." I love the song and the epic 11/22/1995 "Free" was my proper initiation into the band's live show. I didn't care that there wasn't a jam. Next up, "Possum" is one of those songs that I seem to see too many of, including one from two nights before. This one was better than Mansfield, I'd say. Back in the day I recall catching my first "Possum" at the Clifford Ball and being thrilled about it, but today it no longer does the same thing for me.
"Big Black Furry Creature from Mars" is fun. I'll take one any time. Fishman is punk. I busted out some pit dance moves that probably confused people near me. Basically, all I can say is that if you're a square and can't enjoy this song, there is nothing I can write here that could possibly help to clue you in. If this was 1997 or something, I might have complained about a "Swept Away"->"Steep," but not tonight. I enjoyed it, and it reminded me of good times listening to _Billy Breathes_. Lots of couples slow-dancing around us. "David Bowie" was another repeat from Mansfield, but I was OK with that because it's "...Bowie!" "Julius" does not do a lot for me, I have to confess. A dude next to me was screaming and carrying on through it and I sincerely tried my damnedest to interpret what it was he was enjoying that I wasn't, but no dice. I was tired at this point and getting sore from standing, and I guessed that maybe "Golgi..." was the closer. I had a fresh memory of waiting in 2 hours of lot traffic to get out of Mansfield, so we decided to start hiking. I couldn't believe it when a "Fluffhead" started up! So, this had to be the set-closer... or was it? I checked out mobile Twitter feed on my phone and saw that I missed another "Joy." I will make the absolutely embarrassing confession that I walked out on the encore of Camden 2009 and missed the debut of "Joy." Sigh. Oh well. I like the song. I'd like to see it, but too exhausted to have risked sitting in more traffic.
This is very likely the last Phish show I will see this year, and it was a good one in its own special way. No show I've seen in the current era has been perfect and every one has in fact been riddled with the same types of bizarre problems, and I'm learning to live with it. Getting lawn tickets through the lottery when pavilions didn't sell out on the on sale date is the perfect metaphor for the kind of risk you take when you decide to buy a ticket. I would absolutely advise anyone against subjecting the show they see to the type of needless overanalysis that I've employed here. Have fun, travel safe, quit complaining, and may a tree of knowledge in your soul grow!
- Buy and download the concert at LivePhish.com
- An Odd Night in Jersey by Mr. Miner
- Charlie Dirksen's Review of Camden
- Michael Granit's Photos from Camden
- Tyler Curtis' Photos from Camden




